PUNISHING a child, even with the mild naughty step', may suppress bad behaviour, but probably won't stop it happening again, according to a new expert on the parenting block.
What will stop it happening again, says the man heralded as America's most eminent living child psychologist' is simply getting the child to practise the good behaviour you want instead, and then heartily praising them for doing it.
Such an approach, says Dr Alan Kazdin, isn't a quick fix. But with repeated practice of what he calls positive opposite' behaviour, children of any age will automatically start using the alternative good behaviour their parents want to see.
Kazdin, director of the Yale University Parenting Centre and Child Conduct Clinic, says: "Almost every parent now has been exposed to star charts, praise and all of that, and almost always they're doing it incorrectly.
"Take time out', for example; it suppresses the behaviour then, but it won't lead to long-term changes."
He says the "vast majority" of parenting books are based on information that's now known to be wrong, but says his own book, Parenting Your Defiant Child, is rooted in decades of research on how to develop positive behaviour and eliminate undesired behaviour.
However, he insists: "The book isn't about disparaging the advice in other books; what it's about is what you do before behaviour, and then how you praise it afterwards. If you do it this special way, the results are unbelievable."
To illustrate his method, Kazdin uses the example of a child having a tantrum - although he stresses that the time for the child to learn the positive opposite' of their behaviour is when they have calmed down afterwards.
The parent should tell the child they're going to play a game, with the same scenario that caused the tantrum. But in the game he can't get angry and he can't hit mummy, and if he manages that, he can have a star for his star chart, which will ultimately lead to a purposeful' reward.
If the child does this, says Kazdin, the praise should be effusive, and the parent should touch him. The game' should then be practised, say four or five times a week for a few weeks - by which time the positive behaviour should be the child's automatic response.
"The child has to know what he can get ahead of time - the programme is about antecedents and consequences. The process changes the brain and it will lock it in as a habit."
He points out that humans are "hard-wired" to pick up negative behaviour. "Don't focus on what the child shouldn't do - turn it around, and look at the child's positive behaviours. If you punish, it won't suppress the behaviour, except at that moment."
He stresses that his method doesn't need to be used long-term, pointing out: "The intention is that you build the frame of the method around your child's changing behaviour, but that once the desired behaviour takes deeper root you quickly scale down the frame and then take it down entirely."
Aside from an improvement in children's behaviour, Kazdin claims his method also improves life for parents.
"It's about getting parents to act in a different way. Once they practise alternatives to punishment, they get results from their child. Parental stress and depression go down, family relationships improve and home life is made much less stressful."
Parenting Your Defiant Child is published by Piatkus. Priced £10.99. Available now.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article